The infamous “sell me this pen” scenario is a classic test of sales skills and a staple in the world of marketing lessons. But let’s be real, has this exercise become a bit overused and cliché? Has “Sell me this pen” become the most commonly used (and perhaps, slightly worn-out) marketing lesson of all time?
Let’s see…
The Origins of “Sell Me This Pen”:
First things first, let’s give credit where it’s due. The “sell me this pen” challenge gained fame thanks to the movie “The Wolf of Wall Street,” where Leonardo DiCaprio’s character uses it to test the sales prowess of his team. It’s a simple yet effective way to assess someone’s ability to pitch a product and create demand.

While “sell me this pen” has its merits in teaching fundamental sales techniques like identifying customer needs, highlighting product benefits, and creating urgency, it’s been repeated so often that it’s become a bit of a cliché. We’ve seen it in job interviews, training workshops, and countless memes across the internet. It’s almost as if everyone’s trying to outsmart the pen-selling challenge.
But hey, let’s not dismiss the brilliance behind the concept entirely. “Sell me this pen” is a reminder of the art of persuasion, the power of storytelling, and the importance of understanding customer needs. It’s a witty way to showcase sales skills and creativity, even if it has become a bit predictable.
How about turning the tables and asking, “Why do you need this pen?” Suddenly, the focus shifts from selling a product to understanding the customer’s motivations, pain points, and desires. It’s a subtle shift but one that adds depth and complexity to the exercise.
So how do you respond to the “Sell me this pen” challenge?
Here’s one scenario :
Customer: “Sell me this pen.”
Salesperson: “Absolutely, let me tell you about this amazing pen. Imagine yourself in a meeting, about to sign a crucial contract or jot down important notes. What you need is not just any pen, but a reliable tool that enhances your writing experience and makes a lasting impression.”
Customer: “Interesting, tell me more.”
Salesperson: “This pen right here is more than just a writing instrument; it’s a symbol of elegance and functionality. With its smooth ink flow and ergonomic design, every stroke feels effortless and precise. It’s perfect for busy professionals like you who demand nothing but the best in their everyday tools.”
Customer: “I like the sound of that. But why should I choose this pen over others?”
Salesperson: “Great question. This pen stands out because of its durability and versatility. Whether you’re writing on paper or signing documents, this pen delivers consistent performance and leaves a bold, professional impression. Plus, it’s refillable, so you can enjoy its benefits for years to come without worrying about running out of ink.”
Customer: “I see the value in that. How about the price?”
Salesperson: “I understand the importance of value for money. That’s why this pen offers exceptional quality at an affordable price point. And to sweeten the deal, I can offer you a special discount today as a valued customer.”
Customer: “You’ve convinced me. I’ll take it.”
Salesperson: “Fantastic choice! You won’t be disappointed. Here’s your new favorite pen, ready to accompany you on your journey of success and productivity. Thank you for choosing quality and reliability.”
This sample pitch emphasizes the pen’s features, benefits, and value proposition while engaging the customer in a conversation that leads to a successful sale.
But it is a tad too boring. Let’s try again…
Scenario 2 :
Customer: “Sell me this pen.”
Salesperson: “Ah, this pen! It’s not just a pen; it’s your secret weapon for conquering the world, one signature at a time. Imagine wielding this pen in the boardroom, commanding attention with every stroke of genius.”
Customer: “I’m intrigued. Tell me more.”
Salesperson: “Well, let me paint you a picture. This pen is like a superhero in disguise, with its sleek design and super-smooth ink flow. It’s the Batman of pens, always ready to save the day and make your writing tasks a breeze.”
Customer: “I like the superhero analogy. But why should I choose this pen?”
Salesperson: “Because, my friend, this pen is the James Bond of writing instruments. It’s classy, reliable, and always gets the job done with style. Plus, it’s refillable, so you can keep it by your side for all your secret agent missions.”
Customer: “You make a compelling case. What about the price?”
Salesperson: “Ah, the price! It’s a steal, really. Think of it as a VIP ticket to the exclusive club of pen aficionados. And just for you, I’ll throw in a complimentary invisible ink cartridge.”
Customer: “You’ve convinced me. I’ll take it.”
Salesperson: “Excellent choice Your new pen awaits, ready to unleash your creativity and conquer the world.”
This pitch adds a playful touch to the “sell me this pen” challenge while highlighting the pen’s features and benefits in a fun and engaging way.
Nice. But is it enough? Let’s try once more….
Scenario 3 :
Customer: “Sell me this pen.”
Salesperson: “Absolutely, let me introduce you to this fabulous pen. It’s not just any pen; it’s your new best friend in the world of writing. Picture yourself in a meeting, signing documents like a pro with this sleek, stylish pen. It’s like having a magic wand that turns words into wonders.”
Customer: “I like the sound of that. Tell me more.”
Salesperson: “This pen is more than meets the eye. It’s a multitasking marvel, perfect for jotting down ideas, sketching doodles, or even impressing your colleagues with your impeccable handwriting. Plus, it’s so comfortable to hold that you’ll never want to put it down.”
Customer: “I’m intrigued. What sets this pen apart?”
Salesperson: “Glad you asked! This pen is like the James Bond of writing instruments – smooth, sophisticated, and always ready for action. It’s got the perfect balance of style and substance, making it a must-have accessory for anyone who values quality and flair.”
Customer: “Sounds impressive. What about the price?”
Salesperson: “Ah, the price! It’s a steal, really. Think of it as an investment in your writing journey. And to sweeten the deal, I’ll throw in a lifetime supply of creativity and inspiration, absolutely free.”
Customer: “You’ve got me sold. I’ll take it.”
Salesperson: “Fantastic choice! Your new pen is not just a writing tool; it’s a statement of elegance and excellence.
This pitch combines persuasive elements with a touch of humor and panache to create an engaging and memorable sales conversation.
Ultimately, “sell me this pen” is more than just a test; it’s a reminder that effective marketing is about empathy, communication, and problem-solving. Whether you’re selling pens, cars, or software solutions, the key is to listen, connect, and deliver value that resonates with your audience.
So, is “sell me this pen” the most commonly used marketing lesson? Perhaps. But behind the cliché lies a timeless truth – the art of selling is about understanding people, telling compelling stories, and creating meaningful connections. So go ahead, sell me that pen, but don’t forget to add your own witty twist to the tale.
Which scenario is your favourite? Do let me know in the comments section.